09-10-2013, 05:57 PM
Quote:A 24-70 zoom meshes well with something that ends at 24mm, like a Tokina 12-24/4 or Sigma 12-24/4.5-5.6. I've hardly ever seen anyone who is content with having 24mm as their widest even on FF, but they buy a 16/17-35 lens which has a lot of overlap. So if you're going to have a dedicated wide anyways, a 24-70 makes perfect sense on APS-C as well, unless you need to shoot a lot around the 24mm mark and end up switching lenses all the time. Personally I don't understand the "24-70 doesn't cut on APS-C" notion... it just becomes a strictly standard zoom. After all, nobody blasts the 70-200 for not being something it is not, like a standard zoom to cover all bases.The design problem is with the Canon mount version, which sets the aperture electronically. As far as I know, the Nikon version has a mechanical aperture operation, and so for the Nikon mount the problem does not occur.
I plan to use 24-70 as my walk around lens.. since my shooting range mostly here... but I also need and WA, I have D5100 and D7000 but use D7000 mostly, and my plan to use D5100 on WA and D7000 for walk around camera
OTT, I liked the Tokina 12-24/4 when I had it, but others have reported that it is suffering from an inherent design problem that is going to cause malfunction sooner or later. I don't remember what it was though. Sigma 10-20/4-5.6 was also a decent lens (including usage on APS-H for fun), but probably rather slow by the standards of today's APS-C UWA zooms.
ah thank you for telling me this (Tokina 12-24) could you please send me the link regarding this issue.. will look around
