08-06-2010, 09:37 AM
[quote name='geriatric' timestamp='1281076516' post='1534']
Hi, This may have been entered before, but I need to know the answer. The Tamron 28-75mm lens on Canon and Nikon verdicts are different.Nikon say resolution very good, while Canon say not to good. Is this because Nikon test it as a crop and Canon as full frame. The lens being poor on the periphery. One remarked "A good lens if you get a good one" Is it a case of "you pays your money and you takes a chance".
[/quote]
Why should the verdicts be the same here ? Full format tests are something entirely different.
Hi, This may have been entered before, but I need to know the answer. The Tamron 28-75mm lens on Canon and Nikon verdicts are different.Nikon say resolution very good, while Canon say not to good. Is this because Nikon test it as a crop and Canon as full frame. The lens being poor on the periphery. One remarked "A good lens if you get a good one" Is it a case of "you pays your money and you takes a chance".
[/quote]
Why should the verdicts be the same here ? Full format tests are something entirely different.