07-11-2012, 07:49 AM
[quote name='Brightcolours' timestamp='1341990618' post='19407']
Its actually looks quite good. The nervousness puxavida notes is not too bad, you do not get any double line effects which make a photo "dizzy" or make you wonder if you are drunk. And no outlining which make every "highlight" a feature in itself.
It is just this specific background which is a bit busy and not blurred more, only very few lenses willmake it more creamy in this focal length. Like the Sony STF.
Its fine, not distractive and not ugly.
I do like the photo, very nice.
[/quote]
Well I thought we were evaluating the bokeh as a result on the image, not the factors that it depends on.
I find the bokeh not ok and it's because of the fact that some of the factors are combined in an unfortunate way: busy background (both in shape and color) + distance of the background from the subject + distance from camera to subject + aperture setting. One meter away or closer to subject, or 1 stop smaller aperture for instance could maybe change bokeh dramatically. Because the 135L is a very decent lens also in terms of bokeh rendering. But no DSLR lens can be perfect with that regard, and this image is a good example to show it.
Serkan
Its actually looks quite good. The nervousness puxavida notes is not too bad, you do not get any double line effects which make a photo "dizzy" or make you wonder if you are drunk. And no outlining which make every "highlight" a feature in itself.
It is just this specific background which is a bit busy and not blurred more, only very few lenses willmake it more creamy in this focal length. Like the Sony STF.
Its fine, not distractive and not ugly.
I do like the photo, very nice.
[/quote]
Well I thought we were evaluating the bokeh as a result on the image, not the factors that it depends on.
I find the bokeh not ok and it's because of the fact that some of the factors are combined in an unfortunate way: busy background (both in shape and color) + distance of the background from the subject + distance from camera to subject + aperture setting. One meter away or closer to subject, or 1 stop smaller aperture for instance could maybe change bokeh dramatically. Because the 135L is a very decent lens also in terms of bokeh rendering. But no DSLR lens can be perfect with that regard, and this image is a good example to show it.
Serkan