08-16-2012, 06:24 PM
[quote name='Vieux loup' timestamp='1345125578' post='19798']
You don't have to know anything to see that this lens would be quite nice for landscape shots with most Nikon cameras. Most of us don't shoot with a D800 and even if we do, I don't think what you are describing disqualifies this lens for landscapes even with the D800. The reviewers in this forum do an outstanding job of reviewing lenses and I think you should think twice before using the kind of language and statements you did, particularly when they turn out to be unjustified.![[Image: angry.gif]](http://forum.photozone.de/public/style_emoticons/default/angry.gif)
[/quote]
He did not say much that was "not justified". He was and is very right in the odd behavior of this lens, focus "curvature" wise.
He even is partly right for not liking that PZ does not mention it in the review, or overlooked it.
What you are right about is that he puts it in too strong words.
You don't have to know anything to see that this lens would be quite nice for landscape shots with most Nikon cameras. Most of us don't shoot with a D800 and even if we do, I don't think what you are describing disqualifies this lens for landscapes even with the D800. The reviewers in this forum do an outstanding job of reviewing lenses and I think you should think twice before using the kind of language and statements you did, particularly when they turn out to be unjustified.
[/quote]
He did not say much that was "not justified". He was and is very right in the odd behavior of this lens, focus "curvature" wise.
He even is partly right for not liking that PZ does not mention it in the review, or overlooked it.
What you are right about is that he puts it in too strong words.