11-26-2012, 01:40 PM
[quote name='you2' timestamp='1353935046' post='21076']
For the most part I think it looks decent; better than canon 35f2.
[/quote]
It certainly is quite a bit worse than the canon 35mm f2. the 35mm f2's problem is a 5 sided highlights (when stopped down, obviously), but it has no double line nisen bokeh background problem that this Sigma displays:
http://blog.sigmaphoto.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/IMG_0554.JPG5D-and-35mmf14-1200-e1353525266529.jpg
In reality the 35mm f2 from canon has quite benign bokeh (I should know... I use it with shallow DOF a lot). not the best, but surprisingly good. Obviously you singled out the Canon 35mm f2 from the list I gave because that is the lens I own <img src='http://forum.photozone.de/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/wink.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt='' />/>
Showing quite smooth transitions without a nisen bokeh character wide open:
Stopped down still smooth bokeh, and showing characteristic 5 sided highlights:
Smooth transitions from focus to background blur without double lines, 5 sided highlights obvious:
And more smooth bokeh with no hint anywhere of double line nisen bokeh:
Bokeh wise its main vice is that the 5 sided aperture, when stopped down, can make nasty patterns with lots of highlights.
I do not see such a benign bokeh with the Sigma 35mm f1.4.. Not with the leaf images, not with the Sigma provided images.
For the most part I think it looks decent; better than canon 35f2.
[/quote]
It certainly is quite a bit worse than the canon 35mm f2. the 35mm f2's problem is a 5 sided highlights (when stopped down, obviously), but it has no double line nisen bokeh background problem that this Sigma displays:
http://blog.sigmaphoto.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/IMG_0554.JPG5D-and-35mmf14-1200-e1353525266529.jpg
In reality the 35mm f2 from canon has quite benign bokeh (I should know... I use it with shallow DOF a lot). not the best, but surprisingly good. Obviously you singled out the Canon 35mm f2 from the list I gave because that is the lens I own <img src='http://forum.photozone.de/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/wink.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt='' />/>
Showing quite smooth transitions without a nisen bokeh character wide open:
Stopped down still smooth bokeh, and showing characteristic 5 sided highlights:
Smooth transitions from focus to background blur without double lines, 5 sided highlights obvious:
And more smooth bokeh with no hint anywhere of double line nisen bokeh:
Bokeh wise its main vice is that the 5 sided aperture, when stopped down, can make nasty patterns with lots of highlights.
I do not see such a benign bokeh with the Sigma 35mm f1.4.. Not with the leaf images, not with the Sigma provided images.