[scottburgess]

I think you'll need to give folks a lot more information about your criteria to get much help.  I took a glance at these, and to me they both looked overpriced, with low max weight limits.  Many similar products at 1/4 the price seem to get superior reviews.  It isn't clear to me why you narrowed down to these two--but I do stills, not video, and don't know what your gear weighs, where you plan to take it, what you're filming, etc... 

 

Also, there are multiple tripods listed under each set of numbers--it might help If you were more specific about which leg/head combinations you're considering.  The prices aren't a reliable guide to distinguishing models, as they vary considerably depending on location and dealer.