[davidmanze]

Ok, now it gets a bit out there, sort of. Shooting multi camera productions with not at all good form factor for video mirrorless stills cameras.
So no matter what anyone finds out about the R5, it is a lousy camera? Ok, got you.

Facts still remain.... It does 4K30 and 4K60 in higher quality, with better C-log, higher bitrate, oversampling from 8K, with much better AF for video if desired, much better IBIS for video, much less jello effect, but the A7 III is better, not just in some cases, but all cases. Right?  

Even in multi camera  serious setups, where you record externally for long durations in 4K60, where the R5 apparently does not overheat. Got it, the A7 III is the best.

No BC, it's about corporate dishonesty and not being up front that p.....d me right off .... my sympathies at that point are gone ..... whatever the brand ....... Nikon whoever!!

 In fact I think it is a truly great camera indeed, especially with it's amazing AF system with boggling eye AF .... great image quality, high resolution and build!
  As a stills camera it's hard to beat and knocks the socks off anything Nikon has to offer ...... lenses are great too ....
 The video specs are wonderful no doubt ...... but that overheating !! 
    I watched Gerald Undone's video live while it was streaming and posted the fact here early during it (three hours btw).... so I was seeing how the R5/R6 wqs doing in terms of overheating in "real time" .... my post seemed to go unnoticed, but in reality the Atomos was the camera's saviour. 
  So now it "isn't the same camera situation in terms of video" at all!!
.... Canon published all those remarquable specs which were picked up by the rumour sites and published for all of us to read and wow over, (I was wowing too) ........ the Canon ambassadors duly said wonderful things about IQ , eye AF and video without mentioning the OH issues ....... no doubt under pressure from Canon to keep quiet about it ....... and the pre-orders flooded in!  
.. slowly but surely independent reviewers got their hands on the camera and the camera manual itself ........ and everything started to become public ....... with over heating videos a go go .... the pooh hit the fan (quite rightly IMO)
  ..  Canon knew the camera had overheating problems and said "nothing" about it ...... once revealed that all the OH issues were printed to see in the manual, yet were never mentioned, was in my view, deceitful ..... Canonites felt duped and quite rightly so!
 IMO a camera that overheats and then can take hours before you can even as much as turn it on again is unacceptable to say the least if not forewarned.
 Everybody thought the days of Canon's embargo on consumer video specs was over ....
 So where are we now? ...... the Atomos luckily has come to the rescue and given the R5/R6's great video specs a chance to breathe again, but it's no longer the same game as was advertised on the tin ......... it's not a stand alone video camera!
 ...... you need an Atomos ext recorder and a bunch of gear plus cards, extra batteries, mic and sundries ..... and the will to use it .. and if you want to shoot 8K you will have to wait for the new 8K model ..... and then the most powerful of computers to process it.

   The Sony A7SIII. 
 Less adventurous in it's concepts, it doesn't provide 8K .....however it does provide a good range of 4K options ....... no record time limit, a new level of OVF (which actually interests me, I want to try one) and a system of getting the heat out of the camera ...... (and so so stills resolution) ....... not so great ..... it's a video camera .......... (btw. I'm not so interested in the differences between their 4K specs ...... both produce great 4K video  
 .... what it does have to do however, is work consistently in all modes without anything other than a mic on the camera ....... without overheating !! (I discount leaving the camera running in full Florida sunshine .... once discovered, you provide some sort of small shade and that's the end of it ..... not so the Canon)
 So, it turns out it does what it says on the tin ..... it's a stand alone video camera ..... very few caveats, nothing to hide and no nasty surprises....... Sony was honest there!!


  Which is better is for your needs? .... only the buyer can decide!


 

....  BC, you are a true Canon man ..... loyal to a tee ....... and loyalty is a very honorable quality!!