03-14-2011, 07:08 AM
[quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
it could be sample difference for sure.[/quote]
Great. We agree about at least one possible differentiating factor.
[quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
As far as your religious analogy goes, that's kinda ridiculous. [/quote]
It was a deliberate provocation. All I wanted is to emphasize that your question - as you phrased it - can only be answered by you.
[quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
That's a little misguided - I only posed that question here because I wanted clarification about the differing results. I honestly think both sites are reliable. [/quote]
Great. We agree about another thing. <img src='http://forum.photozone.de/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt='
' />
[quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
The big lesson here though: Don't compare reviews BETWEEN sites, just focus on reviews within each site's system -- and preferably even on the same body.[/quote]
I follow a different route. I think that variability has a strength of it's own. I read all the tests in all the the sites which I think are reliable e.g. DPR, SLRgear, LensTip, PZ, TDP etc. I also read as many as possible user reviews in various sites. Then, when I have a significant amount of info I feel more confident in my view.
it could be sample difference for sure.[/quote]
Great. We agree about at least one possible differentiating factor.
[quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
As far as your religious analogy goes, that's kinda ridiculous. [/quote]
It was a deliberate provocation. All I wanted is to emphasize that your question - as you phrased it - can only be answered by you.
[quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
That's a little misguided - I only posed that question here because I wanted clarification about the differing results. I honestly think both sites are reliable. [/quote]
Great. We agree about another thing. <img src='http://forum.photozone.de/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt='
' /> [quote name='curriguy' timestamp='1300060722' post='6722']
The big lesson here though: Don't compare reviews BETWEEN sites, just focus on reviews within each site's system -- and preferably even on the same body.[/quote]
I follow a different route. I think that variability has a strength of it's own. I read all the tests in all the the sites which I think are reliable e.g. DPR, SLRgear, LensTip, PZ, TDP etc. I also read as many as possible user reviews in various sites. Then, when I have a significant amount of info I feel more confident in my view.