11-09-2012, 02:06 PM
Hi there,
I ended up with a new Canon 15-85mm that is slightly decentered at 85mm wide open. Other focal lengths seem OK to me.
Below are two 100% crops taken with a 10 megapixel camera. The pictures show the 4 corners copied closer together for better comparison.
http://im.bilderkiste.org/1135246865645/test1.jpg
http://im.bilderkiste.org/2135246868663/test2.jpg
The photos are representative of the large number of shots I took. test1.jpg was composed of 4 shots, first focused at infinity with center AF and then recomposed each time to put the tower into one corner. The test chart setup (test2.jpg) was perpendicular and I used AF at the center.
I went through 3 copies of the lens and they were all the same (more or less).
Since the lens test on this site also mentions decentering I would like to ask: is this amount of decentering inevitable for this lens? Would you keep it or hunt for a better copy?
Thanks
Tom
I ended up with a new Canon 15-85mm that is slightly decentered at 85mm wide open. Other focal lengths seem OK to me.
Below are two 100% crops taken with a 10 megapixel camera. The pictures show the 4 corners copied closer together for better comparison.
http://im.bilderkiste.org/1135246865645/test1.jpg
http://im.bilderkiste.org/2135246868663/test2.jpg
The photos are representative of the large number of shots I took. test1.jpg was composed of 4 shots, first focused at infinity with center AF and then recomposed each time to put the tower into one corner. The test chart setup (test2.jpg) was perpendicular and I used AF at the center.
I went through 3 copies of the lens and they were all the same (more or less).
Since the lens test on this site also mentions decentering I would like to ask: is this amount of decentering inevitable for this lens? Would you keep it or hunt for a better copy?
Thanks
Tom